Netflix Series “American Primeval” Review: Potential Controversy for Latter-day Saints

In the realm of modern Westerns, many stories focus on the harsh realities of life on the frontier. Netflix’s “American Primeval” delves deep into these brutal aspects in its six gripping episodes, showcasing mud-soaked landscapes, frigid snowscapes, and intense moments of violence. From wolves attacking cabins to sadistic whippings, the series doesn’t shy away from the darker side of the Old West.

Created by Mark L. Smith, known for his work on “The Revenant,” the show draws inspiration from the Utah War of 1857-58, pitting settlers against the United States. Historical figures like Jim Bridger and Brigham Young play prominent roles in this turbulent period of land disputes and authority struggles.

Director Peter Berg skillfully captures the grit and gunfights of the era, with stunning visuals courtesy of cinematographer Jacques Jouffret. Despite the show’s visual appeal, the narrative sometimes falls flat, lacking depth and excitement. The characters, while well-portrayed, often feel like stereotypes from classic Western films.

The series follows Sara and Devin Rowell as they seek help navigating the dangers of the frontier. Along with a reluctant guide and a runaway Native American girl, the group faces numerous challenges that test their endurance and resilience. However, the plot becomes convoluted, shifting between different storylines without a clear focus.

While “American Primeval” attempts to deliver a revisionist take on the Western genre, it occasionally veers into clichéd territory, straying from historical accuracy in ways that may disappoint some viewers. Despite its flaws, the show offers a dark and intense portrayal of life on the American frontier, shedding light on the savage realities faced by those who dared to challenge the wilderness.