HBO Documentary ‘Nature Of The Crime’ Examines Ineffectiveness of Parole System

In the new HBO documentary “Nature of the Crime,” directors Ricki Stern and Jesse Sweet take a hard look at the parole system in America and question whether it truly allows for rehabilitation. The film follows the stories of Chad Campbell, Carlos Rebollo, and Todd Scott, who committed crimes as teenagers and have spent decades behind bars. As they prepare for their parole hearings, the documentary explores whether the parole board considers the potential for change in these individuals or focuses solely on their past actions.

Campbell, Rebollo, and Scott were all sentenced to long prison terms for their crimes, with only one of them being granted parole after 85 years collectively. The documentary highlights the struggles they face in proving their readiness for release and the challenges of navigating the parole system. Throughout the film, viewers are asked to consider what it means to truly be rehabilitated and how much punishment is justified for crimes committed as teenagers.

The directors emphasize the importance of understanding the complexities of the parole system and the impact it has on those seeking release. They encourage viewers to grapple with questions of remorse, rehabilitation, and redemption, as they witness the struggles of these individuals to prove they are deserving of a second chance.

The film also sheds light on the need for reform within the parole system, with attorneys like Rochelle Swartz advocating for a more thoughtful and compassionate approach to parole decisions. Swartz raises important questions about the role of judges in reviewing parole board decisions and emphasizes the need for greater oversight and accountability in the parole process.

Overall, “Nature of the Crime” is a thought-provoking and challenging documentary that invites viewers to consider the human side of the criminal justice system. It raises important questions about the nature of punishment, the potential for redemption, and the need for reform in America’s approach to parole.