New Documentary on Nick and Aaron Carter Avoids Uncomfortable Truths

Following the tragic passing of Aaron Carter at the age of 34, it’s been a difficult time for fans and media alike. Many millennials fondly remember growing up listening to Aaron’s music and seeing him on popular TV shows like Sabrina The Teenage Witch. However, his struggles with mental health and addiction have been well-documented over the years, shedding light on the hardships of child stardom.

In 2024, a docuseries on Investigation Discovery called Fallen Idols delved deep into Aaron Carter’s challenges, attributing them to his early fame, pressure from his parents to support the family financially, and the strain of being compared to his older brother, Nick Carter from the Backstreet Boys. The series also highlighted Aaron’s support for women who accused Nick of assault, leading him to face online harassment from fans.

Now, Paramount+ is set to release a new two-part documentary called The Carters: Hurts To Love You. The documentary, premiering on April 15, is narrated by Angel Carter, Aaron’s twin sister, and explores the family’s story through never-before-seen home videos and interviews with those close to the Carters.

Unlike Fallen Idols, The Carters takes a narrower approach, focusing solely on Angel’s story. It dives into the dysfunctional family dynamics, trauma, addiction, and neglect that shaped the Carter children’s lives. The documentary is a poignant look at the challenges faced by the family, with heartbreaking insights into their struggles.

While both Fallen Idols and The Carters touch on the family’s past, they each offer a unique perspective on the Carters’ story. The Carters, directed by Soleil Moon Frye, aims to create a safe space for Angel to share her experiences and shed light on the family’s journey through mental health and addiction.

The ongoing legal battles regarding assault allegations against Nick Carter add another layer of complexity to the family’s narrative. Despite these challenges, The Carters strives to tell a heartfelt and emotional story that resonates with viewers, highlighting the resilience and courage of Angel Carter as she opens up about her family’s struggles.