Netflix Movie Review: “Mary” – Finding the Thrill of Hope

I have a lukewarm relationship with Catholic and Christian movies. Every time I settle in to watch one, I hope to be blown away and ready to recommend it to everyone, even those outside the faith. Unfortunately, more often than not, I end up feeling disappointed. Whether it’s the acting, the production value, or the way the story is told, something usually falls short.

The Netflix original film “Mary,” which explores the life of the Virgin Mother in the period surrounding Jesus’ birth, didn’t break the pattern. Produced by Joel Osteen, the movie starts with Mary’s birth and follows her journey with Joseph, fleeing from King Herod’s soldiers, played by Anthony Hopkins. Drawing from a mix of biblical and extra-biblical sources, the film takes some creative liberties that blur the lines between historical accuracy and dramatic flair.

From the opening scenes, the movie sets a dark and somber tone. While visually striking, the mood made me question the narrative’s direction. Anthony Hopkins’ portrayal of King Herod feels haunting, and the appearances of Lucifer and a more menacing St. Gabriel add to the eerie atmosphere. There’s a lack of the expected “thrill of hope,” leaving little room for rejoicing.

Director DJ Caruso aimed to show a more relatable side of Mary, focusing on her struggles and humanity. While the film succeeds in portraying her strength amidst adversity, it falls short in capturing the divine grace that believers associate with Mary. Rather than showcasing hope in the midst of suffering, the movie dwells on the darkness that surrounds her.

While it’s important to acknowledge the hardships Mary and Joseph faced, it’s equally crucial to remember the hope embedded in their story. Good stories reveal the resilience and promise of hope, even in the darkest moments. Ultimately, the message of faith is one of enduring joy, regardless of the challenges we face.

As we navigate our own struggles and setbacks, stories like that of Mary and Joseph offer a beacon of hope. Even when things seem bleak, the promise of a better tomorrow remains. In a season meant for reflection and anticipation, a film like Netflix’s “Mary” may not resonate with those seeking a message of hope in storytelling.