Apple TV+ Review: Billy Crystal’s Tedious Therapy-Speak Masquerading as Drama
A new TV show titled "Before" has captured attention with its intriguing premise. The series opens with a young boy desperately seeking help from psychiatrist Dr. Eli Adler, played by the renowned actor-comedian Billy Crystal. Crystal’s portrayal of Adler as a serious and anguished character sets the tone for the show, hinting at deeper themes to come.
Before delves into complex ideas about past lives, connections across time, and the profound impact of grief on identity. However, despite its ambitious concepts, the show struggles to deliver a compelling narrative that resonates with viewers. The character of Dr. Adler, initially presented as a man of science skeptical of mysticism, quickly embraces the idea of reincarnation when faced with the troubled Noah, played convincingly by Jacobi Jupe.
As the story unfolds, Before becomes mired in its own pretensions, failing to explore its intriguing themes with the depth and nuance they deserve. The narrative meanders through repetitive moments of anguish and introspection, stretching thin character arcs over ten episodes. The focus on Noah’s turmoil and Dr. Adler’s quest for meaning begins to feel tiresome, lacking the emotional impact that the show aims to achieve.
Despite moments of striking cinematography and introspective dialogues, Before falls short of making a lasting impression. The series struggles to balance its philosophical musings with engaging storytelling, leading to a sense of stagnation and predictability. The supporting cast of medical professionals adds little depth to the narrative, serving mainly as foils for Dr. Adler’s internal struggles.
Ultimately, Before fails to live up to its initial promise, leaving viewers with a sense of disappointment and familiarity. The show’s exploration of profound themes is overshadowed by a lack of narrative momentum and character development. While Crystal’s performance as Dr. Adler is commendable, it is not enough to elevate Before from its descent into melodrama and cliché.
In conclusion, Before may captivate audiences with its tantalizing premise and star-studded cast, but it ultimately falls short of delivering a truly compelling and thought-provoking viewing experience.
